»
S
I
D
E
B
A
R
«
Bones’ Possible Asperger’s Connection
March 1st, 2010 by Lynn DeVries


[Photo: © 2010 FOX Broadcasting Co.]

I have a friend with Asperger’s syndrome. It’s a very high-functioning form of autism and it’s more common than you may think. And it’s even possibly closer to home than many Bones fans think.

I have actually wondered if perhaps our favorite forensic anthropologist could have a form of Asperger’s, but didn’t dare bring up the subject to other Bones fans, for fear of being attacked in the comments. But if you or someone you know has Asperger’s, you know it’s not such a big surprise.

Tomorrow night the new drama Parenthood premieres and one of the children is diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome. So an article on NJ.com looked into the way that people with autism are dealt with on TV. One of the people they talked to was Hart Hanson, creator of Bones. Here are several paragraphs from the article, but I encourage you to go read it in its entirety:

“Parenthood” is not the first TV show to feature a regular character with the condition — but it’s one of the first to openly acknowledge that. Both physicist Sheldon Cooper played by Jim Parsons on the CBS sitcom “Big Bang Theory” and forensic anthropolgist Temperance Brennan (Emily Deschanel) on the Fox crime drama “Bones” would appear to be classic “Aspies,” as many of those with the condition call themselves. They are smart and focused on subjects they care about, but have great difficulty understanding rules of social interaction that come easily to those around them — all classic Asperger symptoms.

“Bones” creator Hart Hanson says he based Brennan in part on an Aspie friend, but the needs of a broadcast network like Fox to get as large an audience as possible meant he couldn’t come out and say that.

“If we were on cable, we would have said from the beginning that Brennan has Asperger’s,” Hanson says. “Instead, it being a network, we decided not to label a main character, for good or for bad. But those elements are in there.”

Now that “Bones” is an established hit, Hanson has thought about a storyline for next season where Brennan explores the idea that she has Asperger’s. But he shares the concern of the “Big Bang” writers.

“We’d have to get it absolutely right,” Hanson says. “If you don’t get it right, you’re damaging people.”

I say that it’s time to address the issue and the character completely. People with Asperger’s are very capable of having good relationships and living rewarding lives. It’s time that TV showed it for what it is.

What are your thoughts about the possibility of Brennan having Asperger’s? Does it make a difference in the way you view the character? Does it help give a better understanding of both Asperger’s and Brennan?

I welcome your respectful comments.


6 Responses  
  • Lisa Salvatore Szpryngel writes:
    March 9th, 2010 at 12:51 AM

    From myprofessioanl research on Asperger’s, as well as people I know with the “disorder”, I can see where people may think Brennan has a “slight” form of Asperger’s.
    However, I posit that the reason for Brennan’s social awkwardness comes from two other issues: 1.) People with very high IQ are often socially awkward- they just do not think the same way that the person with “average or above average ” intelligence think- they just do., 2.) There is nothing in 5 seasons that gives us information that Brennan struggled socially as a child(except that she was so bright). It was not until her parents disappeared when she was 15 and sent to the foster system- a very challenging time for a teenage going through puberty. Asperger’s is something a person is born with, not develops later.
    Thats my viewpoint. Thanks

  • Lynn writes:
    March 9th, 2010 at 12:52 AM

    Lisa: Thanks for the insight! I appreciate the information! :-)

  • Megan writes:
    June 28th, 2010 at 3:08 PM

    I agree with Lisa – Brennan shows the typical social awkwardness associated with high intelligence and we are never given any indication that she was so awkward as a kid, pre-abandonment. It’s very possible that Brennan has AS, but then again we don’t know whether her behaviour was innate or learned (due to her traumatic childhood). I mean, one of the big symptoms of AS is lack of empathy, but Brennan (especially in Season One) was deeply moved by the tragedy all her victims went through, saying she could almost feel their pain (or something along those lines).

    I’ve always had a feeling that her social awkwardness is kind of a defence mechanism; by remaining distant and alienating those around her, she can avoid the pain she deems inevitable in relationships (because her family, who she trusted so dearly, abandoned her and put her through unimaginable emotional pain). I think her inability to relate to pop culture and sarcasm etc. could just be a result of her being pretty much alone for most of her life – without family, friends or stable, long-term relationships she preferred to focus on her studies than getting out and having a social life etc. She said in the 100th Episode (flashback) that she didn’t follow current affairs past the Industrial Revolution – it’s possible that she just isn’t interested by pop culture at all, and not being exposed to it naturally the way we all are, it just passed her by.

    I really don’t think they should ever definitively diagnose Brennan with AS (or say she definitely doesn’t have it). I don’t see why it’s necessary to give everyone a label. I mean, Zach clearly had AS (Emily Deschanel commented on this at one stage, I think) but no one ever felt it necessary to actually say that on the show. He was just…Zach. Brennan is just Brennan, she doesn’t need any more labelling than that :P I also think it would be odd for Brennan to suddenly start questioning this at 34. If she was to become suspicious that she had AS at all, it would have been a long time ago.

    Anyway I really don’t think the fans care if Brennan actually has a disorder or not – we’ve grown to love her as she is, no labels required :D

  • JoJerome writes:
    July 5th, 2010 at 2:16 AM

    Speaking as an adult with Asperger’s…

    This is the first I’ve heard that Hart Hanson fully acknowledges the Aspie influence. And I get, especially with FOX, the reluctance to ‘label’ the character out of the starting gate. Unfortunate, but I get it.

    And if they are going to say the ‘A’ word on the show, they would do well to explore Asperger’s from its neurological roots instead of merely common traits. Especially since, probably for the sake of keeping the character a Hollywood Hottie, she is not your typical Aspie. For instance, few of us would know how to dress nearly that well or be the least bit comfortable in heels. ;-)

  • Melinda writes:
    September 5th, 2010 at 9:47 PM

    Oh I personally would not change my view of Brennan’s character simply because of Asperger’s. That would be completely illogical. I mean after five seasons,almost six, I love her character for what it is. Giving it a NAME wouldn’t make much of a difference.

  • Ketutar writes:
    October 5th, 2010 at 1:50 PM

    I have Aspergers’, I dress well, I am comfortable in high heels and I have heard I’m a hottie, so…? It’s not that there is a “typical” way Aspies look, is there? :-D
    It’s more in the “what to do with it” aspect that bothers me :-D I didn’t realise my husband-to-be was flirting with me before the third date or something :-D I thought we were just friends :-D He practically needed to spell it to me :-D

    I think Bones is a very typical female Aspie.


Leave a Reply

»
S
I
D
E
B
A
R
«
»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa
© 2010 Lynn DeVries, all rights reserved